Picking banks + squads = cheating ?

Discussion in 'Trapshooting Forum - Americantrapshooter.com' started by Live Oak, Apr 7, 2018.

  1. Live Oak

    Live Oak Well-Known Member

    Ok, I will say it. Picking your squad and banks are a form of cheating. Is trapshooting a competition or not? Not even Tiger Woods gets to pick who he plays with or what hole he has to play.
     
  2. grizquad

    grizquad Well-Known Member Founding Member

    Live Oak, I beg to differ on part of your issue. Picking and pre registering for your squad and the time of day you want to shoot is perfectly fine IMO. I feel the banks should be drawn (not in the back room) prior to the start of the shoot giving shooters enough time to go to their respective trap. Trap is kind of social and people like to shoot and socialize with people they like. When we make as much money as Tiger does, I guess I will shoot where they tell me!
     
  3. Coffee@7

    Coffee@7 Member

    They also like shooting shooting with pals that will let them claim a bird or two. I guess you would "like" those people. :D
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  4. KS33

    KS33 Active Member

    When did picking squad or banks start?
     
  5. Columbus

    Columbus Forum Leader Founding Member Forum Leader

    Well, for this year mine started a few days ago when I presquadded for the Karen's Cup, the Buckeye and the Ohio State shoot picking my banks and position.
     
  6. Rosey

    Rosey Mega Poster Founding Member

    No problem paying ahead of time to presquad. Picking an event, squad, and time is fine. But you should not get a bank selection.

    In today's digital world there are are plenty of ways for the shooters to find out what bank they're on. Should draw banks.

    When Stuart holds back the best banks for presquadding,, you are paying to give yourself an advantage.
     
    Michael McGee and wpt like this.
  7. Columbus

    Columbus Forum Leader Founding Member Forum Leader

    Just the opposite Rosey. I'm paying in advance (a whopping $2 per event) to prevent a disadvantage.
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  8. Rosey

    Rosey Mega Poster Founding Member

    Ha, Same thing! What if you presquaded and still ended up on bank 6?

    What presquading does at Cardinal is penalizes the drive ins and people with unsure work schedules. And when 1/2 the full squads walk out after being told they have a choice of banks 5, 6, or 7 it just pisses off more and more very year.

    When shooters are making 3 trips to the CE building to squad one event, it does not eliminate crowds and time squadding.

    Jack should have put up the curtain on those 3 banks, and people wouldn't be bitching quite as much about increased camping rates and golf cart fee.
     
    Michael McGee and wpt like this.
  9. dr.longshot

    dr.longshot Grudge Match Champion Founding Member Forum Leader Grudge Match Champion

    I tend to agree w/Live Oak, The Ohio State Shoot in the 70s, it was random Placement of shooters, you had to look at posted sheets, find your name, Squad & Position. It never affected my shooting.

    All 27 yard shooters were put in a pile shuffled and Drawn, same as 26.25,24,23,22, 21,20, 19 yds.

    Now I guess a computer would do Random Draws, I always like this, you got what you got, You did not have a time of day option.

    FAIR is FAIR all treated alike.

    Trapshooting is a Competetion, Golf is a Competetion, Horse positions are drawn,

    Let's bring back Competetion, a shooter must have the Average 88% or better to keep his yardage w/o being a reduction PERIOD.

    Gary Bryant...............................Dr.longshot
     
    Jakearoo likes this.
  10. dr.longshot

    dr.longshot Grudge Match Champion Founding Member Forum Leader Grudge Match Champion

    Draw Bank Starting System 1 Hour before shoot starts, on each EVENT, Everyday. This is a very Fair way, no one gets multiple banks, the no getting entry sheets w/o paying for the Targets for all shooters, OPTIONS may be picked later and paid for, BUT TARGETS ARE PAID FOR ENTRRIES TAKEN, NO EXCEPTIONS.

    We have people presently pulling full squads, that are on the same squad, to get better time of day to shoot, if targets were paid for every entry taken, if targets are $36.00 , that's $180.00 that is paid for each squad pulled, this will stop a lot.


    GB............................DLS
     
  11. Columbus

    Columbus Forum Leader Founding Member Forum Leader

    "Jack should have put up the curtain on those 3 banks, and people wouldn't be bitching quite as much about increased camping rates and golf cart fee."

    I agree wholeheartedly with that as I stood at the counter writing a check for this years camping fees and was told part of the increase was to pay for those screens. But, to your question about Bank 6... can't (won't) shoot it or Bank 7. Eye problem for me and I just loose the target against that background. Banks 1-4 and Banks 8-12 are ok. I'm not going to be in a shootoff so Bank 5 is no big deal to me. No normal squadding on that one anyway (practice traps). But individual shooters like me aren't the root of the complaint. It's the guys who show up with a full squad at 9:30 on Saturday morning and want to squad together on Bank 3. If you're willing to break up your group there probably wouldn't be an issue. If you know you're going why not just spend the extra couple dollars and presquad. You can always release them and resquad for different banks or times.
     
  12. BRAD DYSINGER

    BRAD DYSINGER The Philosophist Founding Member Member Trapshooting Hall of Fame Member State Hall of Fame

    What needs to be done is walk the trap line like we used to do. That way no bank would be better than any other and the time of day would be what everyone looked at. Draw for East and West lines before shooting starts, odd squads one way even the other and flip ends in the 200 singles events, every body shoots both ends that way.

    We used to skip 10 fields at Vandalia, and no one had a golf cart either, we walked. Today everyone has a golf cart it seems. Brad
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Jan 6, 2019
  13. Columbus

    Columbus Forum Leader Founding Member Forum Leader

    Walk the trap line??? They do flip the 200 at the State shoot, but walk it - holy cow, I don't think there are enough EMT squads in Morrow county to prepare for that.
     
    Jakearoo and wpt like this.
  14. Rosey

    Rosey Mega Poster Founding Member

    The only place I've even come close to walking the line is Middletown, and yes it makes it more fair and competitive. But trapshooters are spoiled now, and walking the line would not be received well.

    I've presquadded before, and we got one bank we requested in one event. No, my squad didn't sit by the phone waiting for the opening day of presquadding to open, and no, we are not "preferred customers". Really? This is what you have to do to get an advantage? and pay for it.....? and the preferred banks are held back for presquad?

    Who in their right mind ever thought this was a fair, legit method to presquad?
     
    Michael McGee likes this.
  15. Columbus

    Columbus Forum Leader Founding Member Forum Leader

    Who in their right mind ever thought this was a fair, legit method to presquad?

    Not quite sure what you mean, what's unfair? You say they hold back preferred banks, how do they do that? I'm sure all banks are available for pre-squadding. It's a first come first serve situation. System works fine for me. ​
     
  16. History Seeker

    History Seeker A NoBody Founding Member Official Historian

    EVERY large shoot, from the State Shoots on up should have the banks selected at random.

    We did this in NY and it worked well...

    Each morning a number was picked, and that number was where the first squad shot.

    If #7 was selected, the first squad shot bank 7, second squad Bank 8 and so on and so forth.

    That eliminated bank picking.

    Simple solution to the problem of bank selection.

    Late signup or re-squading had to shoot the NEXT squad in line.

    If squad 71 was the last squad registered at the time, The next person was on squad 72 until that was filled, etc., etc.
     
    Roger Coveleskie, Rosey, wpt and 2 others like this.
  17. Columbus

    Columbus Forum Leader Founding Member Forum Leader

    The problem as I see it is that there shouldn't be any bad banks. If we're going to have a competition then the field itself should be pretty much the same for all. At CC this is not the case. And this year it was supposed to be all taken care of. The screens they were going to put up, the screens, I was told the big hike in camping fees was going to pay for, would make banks a non-issue. They took the money then used it for something else. No screens, and Bank 5,6,7 remain an issue for many.
     
  18. Rosey

    Rosey Mega Poster Founding Member

    So.......since it's unchanged on banks 5, 6, 7 they should abandon presquad preferred bank selection. You just said "there shouldn't be any bad banks".

    So you agree!
     
  19. Jakearoo

    Jakearoo Mega Poster Forum Leader

    Isn't the ugly truth that many if not most competitive trapshooters are not really capable of too much walking? Its a significantly aging group and not well known for working out and staying trim. :eek:
     
  20. Columbus

    Columbus Forum Leader Founding Member Forum Leader

    Not at all. I'm all for presquadding and picking your banks in advance.
     
  21. oleolliedawg

    oleolliedawg Mega Poster Founding Member

    Never shot in PA I see.
     
  22. Rosey

    Rosey Mega Poster Founding Member

    No, I haven't, but I've heard the stories.
     
  23. oleolliedawg

    oleolliedawg Mega Poster Founding Member

    Let's put it this way. The best banks in PA are worse than banks 5-6-7 in OH. There's no such thing as treeless backgrounds in PA. You complainers are just spoiled. We wish we had it so bad.
     
  24. Rosey

    Rosey Mega Poster Founding Member

    So in Pa. everybody shoots on shitty banks. Sounds fair.
     
  25. oleolliedawg

    oleolliedawg Mega Poster Founding Member

    Everyone except a few prima donnas permanently on bank 3.
     
  26. Garry

    Garry Mega Poster

    How do these shooters get to shoot on bank 3 every time?
     
  27. Family Guy

    Family Guy Mega Poster Founding Member

    I think that a little strong. More challenging for sure. Nothing bad about the PA shoot in my opinion but I don't see why we need to give anyone an advantage.
     
  28. oleolliedawg

    oleolliedawg Mega Poster Founding Member

    I'm not the pre-squader.
     
  29. JohnWick

    JohnWick Active Member

    They presquad for a full squad for the entire shoot and get their form in early. You’d be surprised how few people actually do that and how easy it is to get the bank you want if you do.
     
    T Jordan likes this.
  30. Union Strong

    Union Strong Well-Known Member

    Is that fair to the weekend warrior with a job?
     
  31. T Shot

    T Shot Mega Poster

    The point of pre-squading is to get a bank close to where you park or your motor home is. If there were all good banks you wouldn't care. Most of the club's in the midwest have good backgrounds. Like the WSRC! If you would get out of Ohio & Penn. you would see that.
     
    old682x and T Jordan like this.
  32. Welther

    Welther Active Member

    Wow? That is the reason. All the motorhome parking places are at bank 3 in PA? And they are at banks 5 and 6 at the CC. And at what banks are the motorhomes parked in Indiana? Anyone can post here? LOL
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  33. JohnWick

    JohnWick Active Member

    I’m not sure how you define fair in this case. The folks who shoot the most targets and plan ahead get the first choice. If you wait until the night before the Bruce Springsteen concert to decide to go you aren’t going to get to sit in the front row.

    Actually, in PA, you can wait in line in squadding and get decent banks if you play your cards right. They only presquad so many flights and open more for the walkins. You’ll just be on a later squad which is only a negative on 3 event days.
     
  34. Welther

    Welther Active Member

    I can go to the PA State Shoot the morning of the handicap championship and ask for Bank 3? LOL Tell them you know Oleolliedawg right?
     
  35. JohnWick

    JohnWick Active Member

    Yes. Especially as a single. Only about 1/2 of the flights are held for presquaders, the rest are given to walk ups. It’s not a guarantee of course but if you are patient it is definitely possible.

    I wouldn’t tell them you know Oleolliedog though. You might get put on bank 14 or given directions to Ohio.
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  36. Flyersarebest

    Flyersarebest Moderator Founding Member Forum Leader

    Since you brought it up, if one of us mentioned that place in IL. it would be "bashing", and all the banks are great,
    WHY DID ONLY 2,003 SHOOT THE BIGGEST EVENT OF THE YEAR IN 2017?

    Must not be the background!
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  37. oleolliedawg

    oleolliedawg Mega Poster Founding Member

    If the banks are so great elsewhere why do the vast majority of shooters go to OH and PA State shoots? Oh, it might be because they're closer to the civilized world.
     
  38. oleolliedawg

    oleolliedawg Mega Poster Founding Member

    That's why banks 5 and 6 are so popular in PA? You've got a 90% chance of finding they're the only banks available as a walkin'.
     
  39. JohnWick

    JohnWick Active Member

    I don’t believe that’s true at all, especially as a single. If you and your 4 buddies come strolling into the clubhouse at 10am after stopping at Massers for breakfast and expect to shoot a premium bank, that’s probably not going to happen. But with a little prior planning you’ll be ok. Shoot management isn’t even opening bank 5 anymore except for a few events a year where attendance is maxing us out.
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  40. Rosey

    Rosey Mega Poster Founding Member

    When Jack does put up the curtain, it will be interesting to see how many shooters still presquad. RJStuart probably hates to see that curtain go up.

    The excuse that you want to shoot in front of your camper is a lame one too. There is no guarantee that will happen even if you are the first one to presquad.
     
  41. oleolliedawg

    oleolliedawg Mega Poster Founding Member

    I'll make a suggestion. Send in your pre-squading form and request bank 3 for every event at this years' State Shoot. Wanna bet you'll have wasted plenty of money and got squat-unless you're one of the favorite sons. Let's not forget those who contributed $$ toward the new traps-1'st priority there too. Doesn't leave much-does it?
     
  42. T Shot

    T Shot Mega Poster

    Olleolli if you would get out of the caves of Ohio & Penn. you would see what great places there are. And that people want & do pre-squad for other reasons then good banks! Sounds like the CC & Penn are holes to shoot at.
     
  43. oleolliedawg

    oleolliedawg Mega Poster Founding Member

    Call 'em what you like but they draw far more shooters than cornfields in the middle of nowhere. Well, at least out in those so called fabulous places you can stop your car most anywhere and drop a bomb without seeing another human being for miles. Wow, that's exciting!
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  44. oleolliedawg

    oleolliedawg Mega Poster Founding Member

    Better yet, let's do some numbers. Since the Singles Championship draws app. 1,000 shooters over 12 banks that allows around 16 squads (80 shooters) per bank. That is operating at max. We all know that most other events draw far fewer shooters therefore chances of a walkin' getting bank 3 are almost nonexistent. We also know those 80 shooters are often composed of favorite sons and preferred pre-squadders. I think it's about time PA and OH draw banks in the morning of the event. It sure seems to work in FL. as it eliminates favoritism and increases fairness to all competitors. Pre-squadding should be for times only-not banks.
     
    Garry and dr.longshot like this.
  45. JohnWick

    JohnWick Active Member

    What are we betting? I just sent in my presquad for the keystone open. I believe we shot a ‘preferred bank’ in every event at the state shoot last year.
     
  46. JohnWick

    JohnWick Active Member

    I’m perfectly ok with drawing banks. I hope it happens.

    Like I said, roughly half the flights are held for presquading. The rest are given away to walkins, first come first served. They can’t give away squads that don’t exist if 16 flights per bank are all they can handle....
     
  47. OldSchool

    OldSchool Active Member

    John...
    It is a competition right? So why should you get to pull a whole squad? The op is about choosing "squads and banks." Why choose? Why get to choose? The blue collar weekend warrior cant do that. And some wonder why the ATA is dying.
     
    Garry and Roger Coveleskie like this.
  48. T Shot

    T Shot Mega Poster

    Why can't the so called ( weekend warrior blue collar) do THAT? I pre-squad for my state the Grand & a few other shoots I'm blue collar. What does that have to do with anything?
     
  49. OldSchool

    OldSchool Active Member

    Why cant the Blue Collar worker and weekend warrior take off and pull a squad for a whole week?

    Are you that dumb?
     
  50. OldSchool

    OldSchool Active Member

    hmmm why cant a weekend warrior do the above. Someone give this guy a clue. lololol
     
  51. rickyd

    rickyd Active Member

    Griz, Does that make it more or less fair?
     
  52. Mike J

    Mike J Mega Poster Forum Leader

    Why don't they do the pre-squadding on Presquad.com?? Everyone has an equal shot there.
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  53. oleolliedawg

    oleolliedawg Mega Poster Founding Member

    Sure, and the same shooters end up on the same banks year after year.
     
  54. Mike J

    Mike J Mega Poster Forum Leader

    Guess you never used the service. It is first come first choice. Couple squads (not banks) are sometimes held by management, but most time you get your time and bank if you book early.
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  55. STaT mAn STaN

    STaT mAn STaN Mega Poster

    The good bank is 5% of the banks at PA. How can most of the people get on that bank? Must be a big bank.
     
  56. grizquad

    grizquad Well-Known Member Founding Member

    Rick, IMO presquadding doesn't affect any fairness. You can do the same thing by showing up early or late to the shoot and squadding with friends or not. If the banks are drawn out in the open just prior to shooting, it doesn't affect the you picking the field you shoot on, just the time and who you shoot with. Pre squadding just makes it easier for people driving to a shoot. I like to pre squad early in the afternoon so I can shoot and not get stuck in traffic going home. I hope that answers your question.
     
  57. Mike J

    Mike J Mega Poster Forum Leader

    Well I should have said you need to try to be first in line as soon as the Pre squad opens. They tell you exactly which minute the pre squad starts. I understand for the Connecticut Sate Shoot if you don't pre squad within the first hours you can forget about getting your first choice. After a day, you will be lucky to get a spot to shoot in the program.
     
  58. Kiehl

    Kiehl Well-Known Member

    And picking those that might give you a target or two.
    It might give you a better time to shoot, better conditions etc.
     
  59. OldSchool

    OldSchool Active Member

    And if you have a job that does not permit you to have that exact minute / hour available....too bad. You can bet the sponsored shooter has his squad long before that.
     
  60. Mike J

    Mike J Mega Poster Forum Leader

    Have a friend do it or go to the bathroom with your smartphone and do it. There is always a way to get things done if you want to.
     
  61. OldSchool

    OldSchool Active Member

    Here is another way. Make it fair so all have an equal chance or like FG wrote on another thread. Go to a shoot or org that is fair.

    I am looking forward to the new org or series coming.
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  62. grizquad

    grizquad Well-Known Member Founding Member

    Kiehl, It just might give me everything you just mentioned, and the wind might just BLOW 50 mph when I shoot, and the trap might start throwing broken birds when I shoot, and it may thunder & Lightning...........I could go on forever
    Everyone just needs to GET OVER IT...........as long as they offer Pre Squadding people are going to use it. Everyone needs to quit bitchin and if enough people don't like something, change the rules.......Thats why they have rules and limits
     
    HistoryBuff likes this.
  63. T Shot

    T Shot Mega Poster

    Old school why do I have to pre-squad for the whole week? If I only shoot a few days I can squad for what I want. But I'm not a big dog.
     
  64. Dave Berlet

    Dave Berlet State HOF Founding Member Member Trapshooting Hall of Fame Member State Hall of Fame

    Maybe thats why your bark is so squeaky???!

    Dave Berlet
     
  65. OldSchool

    OldSchool Active Member

    Tshot....why cant you follow the thread? That was a quote from another person. Are you senile or a child?
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  66. Rosey

    Rosey Mega Poster Founding Member

    3 years ago my squad did the presquad thing for the Ohio State Shoot 1 week after presquad opened. It was quite the ordeal for us to get commitments and agreement when everyone could be there and what events we would shoot. Some guys don't care to shoot doubles! Some won't shoot 3 events in a day. All of us have a camping package, but some can't get there till Wednesday. These are all long time friends, and cutting someone out because they can't confirm a date they'll be there would offend some, and in some cases jeopardize friendships.

    We signed up for Thursday thru Sunday. All the events. We got a requested bank on 1 event. We never got stuck on 5-7, but shot most events on 1, 8, 9,. We've never presquadded again.

    That's not the big problem though. The problem is when a full squad wants to shoot and they walk into the CE building and are told they have to shoot banks 5-7, and no other banks will open till those are filled......and they were in the CE building at opening time! Then you have to make 3 trips back to see if RJ Stuart has finally agreed to open other banks, which can be just after the event starts to 1 hour after it starts. Many times they close it down again, and you have to go back a third time!

    I don't know what the percentage of shooters is between "drive ins" and campers, but every drive in shooter that hasn't presquadded will be affected by this as well. Especially if it's a 3 shooter or full squad.

    This pisses off people. Those same shooters are just going to wait till Stuart opens additional banks anyway, so instead of forcing them to make multiple trips back to the CE building, why not just keep the better banks open, sign up those full squads right then and there, and if it extends the event so be it. It will anyway, cause they are going to wait to sign up on an acceptable bank anyway after Stuart finally opens up squading on better banks!

    When the CC has events run late into the afternoon, and people quit signing up because they realize they'll be shooting when the sun is setting because it's getting too late, or shoot offs are affected, maybe they'll finally realize the current system isn't working. Heck, we shot doubles last year at 7:00 PM, yet banks 5-7 were nearly empty in the first 48 -60 squads!

    It's about presquad $$$ and RJ Stuart's attitude. Jack and the OSTA have to realize it is affecting their customers.
     
  67. robb

    robb Well-Known Member

    Without some form of presquadding I don't think CC could handle the lines waiting to squad.
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  68. OldSchool

    OldSchool Active Member

    I don't see where the OP mentioned the CC. Indian State Shoot does it with ease. Vandalia could do it. That was before computers and with a much bigger crowd.
     
  69. robb

    robb Well-Known Member

    The post above mine referenced the CC. No offense to the OP intended. I'll hold up my hand next time.